Should farm data be processed in the cloud or right where it is collected? It is one of the most practical questions in digital agriculture, and OpenAgri set out to answer it with evidence rather than opinion. In each of our five Sustainable Innovation Pilots, the same solution was deployed in two ways and measured side by side for a full season.
Two ways to run the same solution
In Cloud mode, data such as images or sensor readings is sent over the internet to remote servers, which do the heavy processing. In Edge mode, processing happens on the farm, on a tractor, a drone or a small local computer, and only compact results are sent, if anything is sent at all.
Every pilot then asked farmers and advisors which mode they would actually use. Their answers were not uniform, and that is the most useful result of all.
What farmers chose
Five lessons from Year 1
1. Connectivity is the first filter. Where the signal is weak, Cloud mode struggles. In France, many grazing areas have no reliable coverage, and in Belgium, uploading full-resolution drone images over 3G or 4G can take minutes. In both pilots, farmers chose Edge. 2. Ask what the decision needs to know. When a good decision depends only on what is measured on the spot, such as a beetle on a leaf or a cow at a trough, Edge mode can make it alone. When it depends on outside information, Cloud mode has the edge. In Poland, access to weather forecasts let Cloud mode cut planned irrigation doses before heavy rain, contributing to a 21% higher yield, compared with 6% for Edge. 3.Edge saves bandwidth and energy, often dramatically. In the Greek vineyards, Edge mode sent 700 times less data per session and used 88% less power in the field. In France, it used 43% less energy per day. In Belgium, it completed a detection cycle 22 times faster at 26% lower cost per mission. 4. The accuracy gap is smaller than expected. In Belgium, onboard detection scored a mAP50 of 0.687 against 0.701 in the cloud. In Greece, both modes caught every confirmed disease case. Lightweight models running on small devices proved good enough for real field decisions. 5.Data sovereignty matters to farmers. Concerns about farm data leaving the farm came up repeatedly. Edge mode, which keeps data on-site, was valued for this in Greece and Belgium, and it was also seen as a way to reduce the digital divide.
It is not either/or
The pilots also showed that the choice does not need to be permanent. Greek farmers recommended starting in Cloud mode to collect data and improve the detection models, then moving to Edge. Polish farmers saw Edge as the next step once enough local data has built up. Edge is not automatically cheaper either: in France, Edge mode still required a farm visit to sync data, so only Cloud mode saved time and fuel.
What makes switching possible is openness. All five pilots run on OpenAgri OS-based services and export data in open formats, so a farm can change modes, or suppliers, without losing its data or its history.
The takeaway
There is no single right answer to Cloud or Edge. The right choice depends on the farm’s connectivity, the data a decision needs, and how much control the farmer wants over their data. By testing both modes in real conditions, OpenAgri gives farmers, advisors and AgTech developers the evidence to make that choice for themselves.